Skip to main content

CVE-1999-1382: NetWare NFS mode 1 and 2 implements the "Read Only" flag in Unix by changing the ownership of a file

High
VulnerabilityCVE-1999-1382cve-1999-1382
Published: Fri Dec 31 1999 (12/31/1999, 05:00:00 UTC)
Source: NVD
Vendor/Project: novell
Product: netware

Description

NetWare NFS mode 1 and 2 implements the "Read Only" flag in Unix by changing the ownership of a file to root, which allows local users to gain root privileges by creating a setuid program and setting it to "Read Only," which NetWare-NFS changes to a setuid root program.

AI-Powered Analysis

AILast updated: 06/25/2025, 16:08:37 UTC

Technical Analysis

CVE-1999-1382 is a high-severity vulnerability affecting Novell NetWare's implementation of NFS (Network File System) modes 1 and 2. The vulnerability arises from the way NetWare NFS handles the Unix "Read Only" flag. Instead of enforcing read-only permissions through standard Unix file permission mechanisms, NetWare NFS changes the ownership of a file to the root user to simulate the read-only attribute. This flawed approach allows local users to exploit the system by creating a setuid program, marking it as "Read Only," which NetWare NFS then converts into a setuid root program. Consequently, this grants local users root-level privileges, effectively escalating their access rights on the system. The vulnerability requires local access but does not require authentication, and the attack vector involves manipulating file ownership and permissions via the NFS interface. The CVSS score of 7.2 reflects the high impact on confidentiality, integrity, and availability, with low attack complexity and no authentication required. No patches are available for this vulnerability, and there are no known exploits in the wild, likely due to the age of the vulnerability and the declining use of affected NetWare versions. However, the fundamental flaw in permission handling poses a significant risk to any legacy systems still running vulnerable NetWare NFS implementations.

Potential Impact

For European organizations, the impact of this vulnerability can be significant, especially for those still operating legacy Novell NetWare environments. Successful exploitation allows local users to gain root privileges, which can lead to complete system compromise, unauthorized data access, and potential disruption of critical services. This could affect confidentiality by exposing sensitive data, integrity by allowing unauthorized modification of files or system configurations, and availability by enabling attackers to disrupt or disable services. Organizations in sectors with legacy infrastructure—such as government agencies, manufacturing, and education—may be particularly vulnerable. Additionally, the lack of available patches means that mitigation relies heavily on compensating controls. The vulnerability's local access requirement limits remote exploitation, but insider threats or compromised local accounts could leverage this flaw to escalate privileges and move laterally within networks. Given the strategic importance of critical infrastructure and data protection regulations in Europe, exploitation could also lead to regulatory penalties and reputational damage.

Mitigation Recommendations

Since no official patches are available for this vulnerability, European organizations should implement specific mitigation strategies beyond generic advice: 1) Identify and inventory all systems running Novell NetWare with NFS modes 1 or 2 enabled. 2) Disable NFS modes 1 and 2 on NetWare servers or disable the NetWare NFS service entirely if not required. 3) Restrict local user access to NetWare servers to trusted personnel only, minimizing the risk of local exploitation. 4) Implement strict access controls and monitoring on file creation and permission changes, especially for setuid programs and files marked as read-only. 5) Employ host-based intrusion detection systems (HIDS) to detect unusual privilege escalations or ownership changes on critical files. 6) Consider migrating legacy NetWare systems to modern, supported platforms that do not exhibit this vulnerability. 7) Conduct regular security audits and user privilege reviews to ensure no unauthorized local accounts exist. 8) Use network segmentation to isolate legacy NetWare servers from sensitive network segments to limit lateral movement in case of compromise.

Need more detailed analysis?Get Pro

Threat ID: 682ca32db6fd31d6ed7df66f

Added to database: 5/20/2025, 3:43:41 PM

Last enriched: 6/25/2025, 4:08:37 PM

Last updated: 8/13/2025, 10:04:03 PM

Views: 43

Actions

PRO

Updates to AI analysis are available only with a Pro account. Contact root@offseq.com for access.

Please log in to the Console to use AI analysis features.

Need enhanced features?

Contact root@offseq.com for Pro access with improved analysis and higher rate limits.

Latest Threats