Skip to main content
NewsPublished

Aduna’s Number Verification is a real improvement over SMS OTP. But stronger attestation is not the same thing as stronger identity.

Source Reddit Cybersecurity

0

Discussion

Aduna's Number Verification is a network-based authentication service designed to replace SMS one-time passcodes (OTP) by confirming that a mobile number belongs to the SIM and device making the request. While it improves over SMS OTP by providing fresher and harder-to-intercept attestation, it relies on a single source of trust—the carrier network—which also manages SIM lifecycle and has historically been a target for compromise. This concentration of trust increases the risk that a successful attack on the carrier could enable broader system compromises. The service should be viewed as a stronger witness signal rather than a definitive identity verification, and identity systems should incorporate multiple independent attestations for stronger security.

r/cybersecurity (opens in a new tab)u/BasketOld44820 points0 comments

My argument: carrier network verification should be treated as a better witness, not a final verdict. The real question is not “how strong is this signal?” It is “how many independent witnesses agree, and what would it cost an attacker to compromise all of them?”

I wrote about trust concentration, Salt Typhoon, SMS OTP, and why identity systems need corroboration instead of single-source certainty:

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/hardening-lock-locksmiths-door-niels-goldstein-ewv5e/

References

Community reviews

Loading reviews…