## Summary `TagReference.create()` forwards a caller-influenced positional `reference` value into `git tag` without it ever being inspected by the unsafe-option guard, allowing an arbitrary file read (the file's contents are returned in-band as the annotated tag message). This is an incomplete-fix bypass of commit `3af0c251` (the fix for GHSA-3f7w-8rr8-f37f's tag instance). ## Root Cause The fix `3af0c251` added `unsafe_git_tag_options = ["--file","-F"]` and a guard call, but the guard is `Git.check_unsafe_options(options=Git._option_candidates([], kwargs), unsafe_options=...)` at `git/refs/tag.py:139` — it passes an EMPTY args list and inspects **kwargs only**. The dangerous values `path` and `reference` are POSITIONALS (`args = (path, reference)`, tag.py:156), placed before any `--`. A user-influenced `reference="--file=<path>"` therefore reaches `git tag` as the exact `--file` option the fix intended to block, creating an annotated tag whose message is the file's contents. ## Impact Arbitrary local file read at the privileges of the host process; contents returned in-band via `tagref.tag.message`. Requires the embedding application to forward a caller-influenced `reference` value into `TagReference.create()` (pure VALUE control — the CVE-2026-42215 threat model). Default `allow_unsafe_options=False`. ## Proof of Concept ```python from git import TagReference t = TagReference.create(repo, "vpwn", reference="--file=/home/app/.ssh/id_rsa") print(t.tag.message) # contents of the file ``` ## Attack Chain 1. Entry: app calls `TagReference.create(repo, name, reference=<user>)` with `reference="--file=/home/app/.ssh/id_rsa"`. 2. Check: `Git.check_unsafe_options(_option_candidates([], kwargs), ["--file","-F"])` @ tag.py:137-141. Guard: denylist includes `--file`/`-F`. Bypass proof: `_option_candidates` receives `args=[]` → the positional `reference` is never a candidate (the kwarg spelling `file="…"` IS blocked; only the positional escapes). 3. Sink: `repo.git.tag(*args, **kwargs)` @ tag.py:158 → no `--`. argv (observed): `['git','tag','-f','vpwn','--file=<secret>']`. 4. Impact: annotated tag created; `tagref.tag.message` == file contents (arbitrary file read). ## Bypass Evidence Independently reproduced (independent test harness, git 2.43.0, default `allow_unsafe_options=False`): `TagReference.create(repo,'vp','--file=<secret>')` → PASSED; `tag.message == 'GATE_SECRET_LINE_A\nGATE_SECRET_LINE_B'`. Control: `TagReference.create(..., file='<secret>')` → `UnsafeOptionError: --file is not allowed`. Fix-commit read: `3af0c251` adds `_option_candidates([], kwargs)` (empty args → positional never a candidate). ## Affected Versions `GitPython <= 3.1.58` (sink present verbatim on the latest release tag; `git diff 3.1.57..HEAD` touches only test files). ## Suggested Fix Include the positional `reference` (and `path`) in the option-candidate list passed to `check_unsafe_options`, or place a `--` separator before the positional arguments in `TagReference.create()`. --- Reported by **zx (Jace)** — GitHub: @manus-use