CVE-2025-47278: CWE-683: Function Call With Incorrect Order of Arguments in pallets flask
Flask is a web server gateway interface (WSGI) web application framework. In Flask 3.1.0, the way fallback key configuration was handled resulted in the last fallback key being used for signing, rather than the current signing key. Signing is provided by the `itsdangerous` library. A list of keys can be passed, and it expects the last (top) key in the list to be the most recent key, and uses that for signing. Flask was incorrectly constructing that list in reverse, passing the signing key first. Sites that have opted-in to use key rotation by setting `SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS` care likely to unexpectedly be signing their sessions with stale keys, and their transition to fresher keys will be impeded. Sessions are still signed, so this would not cause any sort of data integrity loss. Version 3.1.1 contains a patch for the issue.
AI Analysis
Technical Summary
CVE-2025-47278 is a vulnerability identified in Flask version 3.1.0, a popular Python web framework that implements the Web Server Gateway Interface (WSGI). The issue arises from incorrect handling of fallback key configuration used for signing session data. Flask relies on the 'itsdangerous' library to cryptographically sign session cookies, ensuring their integrity and authenticity. The library supports key rotation by accepting a list of secret keys, where the last key in the list is considered the current signing key, and the preceding keys are fallback keys used to verify older signatures. However, in Flask 3.1.0, the construction of this key list was reversed, causing the signing operation to use the last fallback key instead of the current signing key. This means that sessions were signed with stale keys rather than the intended fresh key. While this does not lead to direct data integrity loss or session tampering, it impedes the proper transition to newer keys during key rotation, potentially prolonging the use of weaker or compromised keys. The vulnerability is classified under CWE-683 (Function Call With Incorrect Order of Arguments), reflecting the incorrect ordering of keys passed to the signing function. The flaw requires high privileges to exploit (PR:H), no user interaction, and local access (AV:L), resulting in a low CVSS 4.0 score of 1.8. The issue was patched in Flask version 3.1.1. There are no known exploits in the wild, and the impact is limited to key rotation mechanisms in applications that have explicitly enabled SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS. Overall, this vulnerability represents a subtle cryptographic misconfiguration rather than a direct security breach.
Potential Impact
For European organizations using Flask 3.1.0 with key rotation enabled via SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS, this vulnerability could delay or complicate the transition to new signing keys. This may increase the window during which older keys remain in use, potentially exposing session data to risks if those keys are compromised. Although the vulnerability does not allow session tampering or data integrity violations directly, it weakens the cryptographic hygiene of session management. Organizations with strict compliance requirements around cryptographic key management or those subject to regulations like GDPR may face increased risk if key rotation is not properly enforced. The impact is more pronounced in environments with long-lived sessions or where key compromise is a realistic threat. However, since exploitation requires local access and high privileges, the risk of remote exploitation is minimal. The vulnerability does not affect availability or confidentiality directly but may indirectly affect trust in session security. European entities operating critical web applications or services that rely on Flask for session management should prioritize upgrading to Flask 3.1.1 to ensure proper key rotation and maintain cryptographic best practices.
Mitigation Recommendations
The primary mitigation is to upgrade Flask to version 3.1.1 or later, where the key ordering issue has been corrected. Organizations should audit their Flask deployments to identify any instances running version 3.1.0 with SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS enabled. If immediate upgrading is not feasible, temporarily disabling key rotation or SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS can prevent signing with stale keys, though this reduces key rotation benefits. Additionally, organizations should review their key management policies to ensure that secret keys are rotated regularly and securely stored. Implement monitoring to detect unusual session behaviors or anomalies that might indicate misuse of older keys. Security teams should also verify that their deployment pipelines and dependency management tools are configured to promptly apply security patches. Finally, educating developers about the importance of correct key ordering and cryptographic hygiene in session management can prevent similar issues in the future.
Affected Countries
Germany, France, United Kingdom, Netherlands, Sweden, Italy, Spain, Poland
CVE-2025-47278: CWE-683: Function Call With Incorrect Order of Arguments in pallets flask
Description
Flask is a web server gateway interface (WSGI) web application framework. In Flask 3.1.0, the way fallback key configuration was handled resulted in the last fallback key being used for signing, rather than the current signing key. Signing is provided by the `itsdangerous` library. A list of keys can be passed, and it expects the last (top) key in the list to be the most recent key, and uses that for signing. Flask was incorrectly constructing that list in reverse, passing the signing key first. Sites that have opted-in to use key rotation by setting `SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS` care likely to unexpectedly be signing their sessions with stale keys, and their transition to fresher keys will be impeded. Sessions are still signed, so this would not cause any sort of data integrity loss. Version 3.1.1 contains a patch for the issue.
AI-Powered Analysis
Technical Analysis
CVE-2025-47278 is a vulnerability identified in Flask version 3.1.0, a popular Python web framework that implements the Web Server Gateway Interface (WSGI). The issue arises from incorrect handling of fallback key configuration used for signing session data. Flask relies on the 'itsdangerous' library to cryptographically sign session cookies, ensuring their integrity and authenticity. The library supports key rotation by accepting a list of secret keys, where the last key in the list is considered the current signing key, and the preceding keys are fallback keys used to verify older signatures. However, in Flask 3.1.0, the construction of this key list was reversed, causing the signing operation to use the last fallback key instead of the current signing key. This means that sessions were signed with stale keys rather than the intended fresh key. While this does not lead to direct data integrity loss or session tampering, it impedes the proper transition to newer keys during key rotation, potentially prolonging the use of weaker or compromised keys. The vulnerability is classified under CWE-683 (Function Call With Incorrect Order of Arguments), reflecting the incorrect ordering of keys passed to the signing function. The flaw requires high privileges to exploit (PR:H), no user interaction, and local access (AV:L), resulting in a low CVSS 4.0 score of 1.8. The issue was patched in Flask version 3.1.1. There are no known exploits in the wild, and the impact is limited to key rotation mechanisms in applications that have explicitly enabled SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS. Overall, this vulnerability represents a subtle cryptographic misconfiguration rather than a direct security breach.
Potential Impact
For European organizations using Flask 3.1.0 with key rotation enabled via SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS, this vulnerability could delay or complicate the transition to new signing keys. This may increase the window during which older keys remain in use, potentially exposing session data to risks if those keys are compromised. Although the vulnerability does not allow session tampering or data integrity violations directly, it weakens the cryptographic hygiene of session management. Organizations with strict compliance requirements around cryptographic key management or those subject to regulations like GDPR may face increased risk if key rotation is not properly enforced. The impact is more pronounced in environments with long-lived sessions or where key compromise is a realistic threat. However, since exploitation requires local access and high privileges, the risk of remote exploitation is minimal. The vulnerability does not affect availability or confidentiality directly but may indirectly affect trust in session security. European entities operating critical web applications or services that rely on Flask for session management should prioritize upgrading to Flask 3.1.1 to ensure proper key rotation and maintain cryptographic best practices.
Mitigation Recommendations
The primary mitigation is to upgrade Flask to version 3.1.1 or later, where the key ordering issue has been corrected. Organizations should audit their Flask deployments to identify any instances running version 3.1.0 with SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS enabled. If immediate upgrading is not feasible, temporarily disabling key rotation or SECRET_KEY_FALLBACKS can prevent signing with stale keys, though this reduces key rotation benefits. Additionally, organizations should review their key management policies to ensure that secret keys are rotated regularly and securely stored. Implement monitoring to detect unusual session behaviors or anomalies that might indicate misuse of older keys. Security teams should also verify that their deployment pipelines and dependency management tools are configured to promptly apply security patches. Finally, educating developers about the importance of correct key ordering and cryptographic hygiene in session management can prevent similar issues in the future.
Affected Countries
For access to advanced analysis and higher rate limits, contact root@offseq.com
Technical Details
- Data Version
- 5.1
- Assigner Short Name
- GitHub_M
- Date Reserved
- 2025-05-05T16:53:10.373Z
- Cisa Enriched
- true
- Cvss Version
- 4.0
- State
- PUBLISHED
Threat ID: 682cd0fc1484d88663aecbe4
Added to database: 5/20/2025, 6:59:08 PM
Last enriched: 7/6/2025, 5:27:56 PM
Last updated: 8/17/2025, 5:56:05 PM
Views: 32
Related Threats
CVE-2025-5296: CWE-59 Improper Link Resolution Before File Access ('Link Following') in Schneider Electric SESU
HighCVE-2025-6625: CWE-20 Improper Input Validation in Schneider Electric Modicon M340
HighCVE-2025-57703: CWE-79: Improper Neutralization of Input During Web Page Generation ('Cross-site Scripting') in Delta Electronics DIAEnergie
MediumCVE-2025-57702: CWE-79: Improper Neutralization of Input During Web Page Generation ('Cross-site Scripting') in Delta Electronics DIAEnergie
MediumCVE-2025-57701: CWE-79: Improper Neutralization of Input During Web Page Generation ('Cross-site Scripting') in Delta Electronics DIAEnergie
MediumActions
Updates to AI analysis are available only with a Pro account. Contact root@offseq.com for access.
Need enhanced features?
Contact root@offseq.com for Pro access with improved analysis and higher rate limits.