CVE-2024-23342: CWE-203: Observable Discrepancy in tlsfuzzer python-ecdsa
The `ecdsa` PyPI package is a pure Python implementation of ECC (Elliptic Curve Cryptography) with support for ECDSA (Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm), EdDSA (Edwards-curve Digital Signature Algorithm) and ECDH (Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman). Versions 0.18.0 and prior are vulnerable to the Minerva attack. As of time of publication, no known patched version exists.
AI Analysis
Technical Summary
CVE-2024-23342 is a high-severity vulnerability affecting the python-ecdsa package, a pure Python implementation of elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) algorithms including ECDSA, EdDSA, and ECDH. The vulnerability is related to an observable discrepancy identified by tlsfuzzer, which enables a Minerva attack against versions 0.18.0 and earlier. The Minerva attack exploits side-channel information leakage during cryptographic operations, allowing an attacker to recover private keys or forge signatures by analyzing timing or error discrepancies. The vulnerability is classified under CWE-203 (Observable Discrepancy), CWE-208 (Information Exposure Through Error Message), and CWE-385 (Covert Timing Channel), indicating that the implementation leaks sensitive information through observable differences in processing or error responses. The CVSS v3.1 score is 7.4, reflecting high impact on confidentiality and integrity, with no impact on availability. The attack vector is network-based (AV:N), requires no privileges (PR:N), and no user interaction (UI:N), but has high attack complexity (AC:H), meaning exploitation requires specific conditions or detailed knowledge. No patched version is currently available, increasing the urgency for mitigation. The vulnerability affects cryptographic operations that underpin digital signatures and key exchanges, which are critical for secure communications, authentication, and data integrity in software relying on python-ecdsa. Given the widespread use of Python and the popularity of this package in various applications, the vulnerability poses a significant risk to systems that depend on it for ECC-based cryptography.
Potential Impact
For European organizations, the impact of CVE-2024-23342 can be substantial, especially for those relying on python-ecdsa for cryptographic functions in security-sensitive applications such as secure messaging, digital signatures, certificate management, and encrypted communications. Successful exploitation could lead to private key recovery, enabling attackers to impersonate legitimate users, forge digital signatures, decrypt confidential communications, or bypass authentication mechanisms. This compromises confidentiality and integrity of data and communications, potentially leading to data breaches, fraud, and loss of trust. Sectors such as finance, healthcare, government, and critical infrastructure in Europe, which often use ECC for secure communications and identity verification, are particularly at risk. The lack of a patch means organizations must rely on workarounds or mitigations, increasing operational complexity and risk exposure. Additionally, the vulnerability could undermine compliance with European data protection regulations like GDPR if exploited to leak personal or sensitive data. Although no known exploits are currently reported in the wild, the high severity and public disclosure increase the likelihood of exploitation attempts, especially by advanced threat actors targeting European entities.
Mitigation Recommendations
Given the absence of an official patch, European organizations should implement the following specific mitigations: 1) Audit and inventory all software components and dependencies to identify usage of python-ecdsa versions 0.18.0 or earlier. 2) Where feasible, replace python-ecdsa with alternative, well-maintained cryptographic libraries that provide ECC functionality and have no known vulnerabilities, such as cryptography.io or OpenSSL bindings. 3) If replacement is not immediately possible, implement strict network-level controls to limit exposure of services using vulnerable cryptographic operations, including firewall rules and segmentation. 4) Employ application-layer mitigations such as constant-time cryptographic operations and error handling to reduce observable discrepancies, if source code modification is possible. 5) Monitor cryptographic operations for anomalous behavior or timing patterns indicative of side-channel attacks. 6) Engage with the python-ecdsa maintainers and security community to track patch releases and apply updates promptly once available. 7) Enhance logging and incident response readiness to detect and respond to potential exploitation attempts. 8) Educate developers and security teams about the risks of side-channel attacks and secure coding practices for cryptographic implementations.
Affected Countries
Germany, France, United Kingdom, Netherlands, Sweden, Finland, Belgium, Italy, Spain, Poland
CVE-2024-23342: CWE-203: Observable Discrepancy in tlsfuzzer python-ecdsa
Description
The `ecdsa` PyPI package is a pure Python implementation of ECC (Elliptic Curve Cryptography) with support for ECDSA (Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm), EdDSA (Edwards-curve Digital Signature Algorithm) and ECDH (Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman). Versions 0.18.0 and prior are vulnerable to the Minerva attack. As of time of publication, no known patched version exists.
AI-Powered Analysis
Technical Analysis
CVE-2024-23342 is a high-severity vulnerability affecting the python-ecdsa package, a pure Python implementation of elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) algorithms including ECDSA, EdDSA, and ECDH. The vulnerability is related to an observable discrepancy identified by tlsfuzzer, which enables a Minerva attack against versions 0.18.0 and earlier. The Minerva attack exploits side-channel information leakage during cryptographic operations, allowing an attacker to recover private keys or forge signatures by analyzing timing or error discrepancies. The vulnerability is classified under CWE-203 (Observable Discrepancy), CWE-208 (Information Exposure Through Error Message), and CWE-385 (Covert Timing Channel), indicating that the implementation leaks sensitive information through observable differences in processing or error responses. The CVSS v3.1 score is 7.4, reflecting high impact on confidentiality and integrity, with no impact on availability. The attack vector is network-based (AV:N), requires no privileges (PR:N), and no user interaction (UI:N), but has high attack complexity (AC:H), meaning exploitation requires specific conditions or detailed knowledge. No patched version is currently available, increasing the urgency for mitigation. The vulnerability affects cryptographic operations that underpin digital signatures and key exchanges, which are critical for secure communications, authentication, and data integrity in software relying on python-ecdsa. Given the widespread use of Python and the popularity of this package in various applications, the vulnerability poses a significant risk to systems that depend on it for ECC-based cryptography.
Potential Impact
For European organizations, the impact of CVE-2024-23342 can be substantial, especially for those relying on python-ecdsa for cryptographic functions in security-sensitive applications such as secure messaging, digital signatures, certificate management, and encrypted communications. Successful exploitation could lead to private key recovery, enabling attackers to impersonate legitimate users, forge digital signatures, decrypt confidential communications, or bypass authentication mechanisms. This compromises confidentiality and integrity of data and communications, potentially leading to data breaches, fraud, and loss of trust. Sectors such as finance, healthcare, government, and critical infrastructure in Europe, which often use ECC for secure communications and identity verification, are particularly at risk. The lack of a patch means organizations must rely on workarounds or mitigations, increasing operational complexity and risk exposure. Additionally, the vulnerability could undermine compliance with European data protection regulations like GDPR if exploited to leak personal or sensitive data. Although no known exploits are currently reported in the wild, the high severity and public disclosure increase the likelihood of exploitation attempts, especially by advanced threat actors targeting European entities.
Mitigation Recommendations
Given the absence of an official patch, European organizations should implement the following specific mitigations: 1) Audit and inventory all software components and dependencies to identify usage of python-ecdsa versions 0.18.0 or earlier. 2) Where feasible, replace python-ecdsa with alternative, well-maintained cryptographic libraries that provide ECC functionality and have no known vulnerabilities, such as cryptography.io or OpenSSL bindings. 3) If replacement is not immediately possible, implement strict network-level controls to limit exposure of services using vulnerable cryptographic operations, including firewall rules and segmentation. 4) Employ application-layer mitigations such as constant-time cryptographic operations and error handling to reduce observable discrepancies, if source code modification is possible. 5) Monitor cryptographic operations for anomalous behavior or timing patterns indicative of side-channel attacks. 6) Engage with the python-ecdsa maintainers and security community to track patch releases and apply updates promptly once available. 7) Enhance logging and incident response readiness to detect and respond to potential exploitation attempts. 8) Educate developers and security teams about the risks of side-channel attacks and secure coding practices for cryptographic implementations.
For access to advanced analysis and higher rate limits, contact root@offseq.com
Technical Details
- Data Version
- 5.1
- Assigner Short Name
- GitHub_M
- Date Reserved
- 2024-01-15T15:19:19.444Z
- Cvss Version
- 3.1
- State
- PUBLISHED
Threat ID: 6839c41d182aa0cae2b435fd
Added to database: 5/30/2025, 2:43:41 PM
Last enriched: 7/8/2025, 5:12:11 PM
Last updated: 11/29/2025, 10:23:51 AM
Views: 46
Community Reviews
0 reviewsCrowdsource mitigation strategies, share intel context, and vote on the most helpful responses. Sign in to add your voice and help keep defenders ahead.
Want to contribute mitigation steps or threat intel context? Sign in or create an account to join the community discussion.
Related Threats
CVE-2025-6666: Use of Hard-coded Cryptographic Key in motogadget mo.lock Ignition Lock
LowCVE-2025-65892: n/a
UnknownCVE-2025-65540: n/a
UnknownCVE-2025-66221: CWE-67: Improper Handling of Windows Device Names in pallets werkzeug
MediumCVE-2025-53939: CWE-20: Improper Input Validation in kiteworks security-advisories
MediumActions
Updates to AI analysis require Pro Console access. Upgrade inside Console → Billing.
Need enhanced features?
Contact root@offseq.com for Pro access with improved analysis and higher rate limits.